Jack and the Box, by Art Spiegelman

Jack and the Box has all the elements of a successful childrens book; it is created by a veritable powerhouse couple - Editorial Director, Francoise Mouly (Art Editor, New Yorker and founder of RAW Books & Graphics) and Writer/Illustrator, Art Spiegelman (Pultizer Prize winning, “Maus
“), it has a simple storyline, it borrows heavily from the comic book genre and is drenched in colors straight from the kids’ nursery.
The premise of the story is simple enough; Jack, the bunny, gets a box from his parents and there is a little character named Mack who keeps popping out of it. At first, he is scared and a bit put off by Zack but within a few pages he’s demanding him to appear. And with that, Zack brings his friend Mack and all his ducks into the scene.

For most of the ride, Jack and the Box, comes off as a series of classic three panel Sunday comics; the “set-up,” the “conflict” and the “resolution.” Yes, thematically it licks of Dr. Seuss’ revered, “The Cat in the Hat“, but knowing the author’s long history of twisting seemingly simple stories on their head, I have to wonder if this story “speaks” to its target audience (4-8 year old) or does it go over their heads? Or mine for that matter?
As a parent, I feel childrens stories can and should encompass the same basic emotional range as any other piece of literature, so the fact that this story get a little weird or creepy, in theory, is fair game so long as there is some type of solid resolution at the end and the weird or creepy parts are well explained/defined. Yes, it is clear that the Zack & Mack we experience are a figment of Jack’s imagination, but I think it is lost by the younger Readers. There is no hard sell for that big “magical” moment when we ‘pop’ in and out of Jack’s imagination.
I understand there is a limited and attainable vocabulary being used for a reason but the use of “silly” throughout the story comes off as a verbal “twitch” more than anything, and rightly so considering Jack the Bunny is being haunted by a little Zack in the Box.
In the end, I will admit my expectations were quite high for this little book, perhaps too high. But I still admire his work, and have faith in the TOON Books line especially if Ms. Davis is still on their payroll. So, if you are looking to toss your kids into the deep pool that is the comic book genre have them wade through the TOON Book line, what a few years and introduce them to Art’s other work.
Sited Links:
Art Spiegelman | Jack and the Box
Art Spiegelman | Maus
Art Spiegelman | In the Shadow of No Towers
Dr. Seuss | The Cat in the Hat
Eleanor Davis | Stinky
















